This is a continuation of our article Slowdown in Cloud on Thin Ice Following Q1 Guides. Here’s a quick recap”
“Following the most recent earnings reports, our prediction is playing out that the slowdown we had predicted in Cloud would worsen. For example, best-of-breed cloud reported a 71% slowdown in QoQ/YoY growth for Q4 guides and is now guiding for an 83% slowdown in QoQ/YoY growth for Q1 guides.
This is important because the cloud category has treated investors quite well with recurring revenue, resiliency during Covid, and some of the strongest examples of product-market fit available on the public markets. However, not even this can overcome the effects of lower budgets and cloud spend, which is the top driver in terms of year-over-year comparisons.”
Digging Deeper on Best-of-Breed
Our analysis on cloud best-of-breed should not be confused for excessive bearishness. We like this category quite a bit and will continue to watch it closely to build position(s) in the future. Rather, we prefer to not stand in front of the train (which for growth stocks, can be defined as rapid deceleration on the top line) and to simply wait for a signal that growth will resume. Others will choose to remain invested for the long-term story, and that may fit another investment profile.
We took a sample of the top-ranking cloud stocks on revenue growth, free cash flow, adjusted operating margin and/or valuations. Among the best-of-breed cloud stocks, only ServiceNow’s guide shows sequential growth. The company’s QoQ growth was 7% last year and is expected to be 8% this year. In this article we want to expand the data below to see which companies are outperforming and underperforming based on the various metrics.

Source: YCharts

Source: YCharts
We did a similar analysis in December. Since then, Gitlab stands out for its revenue growth profile that increased from a 10% decel to a 16% decel expected for Q1 from the previous year. If this continues, Gitlab will see an approximate 50% decel from FY2022. HashiCorp is also turning negative in terms of QoQ/YoY, as is Bill.com and MongoDB. Two of these stocks lag cloud on YTD returns with Bill down (30.25%) and Gitlab down (27.13%).

Source: YCharts
Earnings Beats
Below we look at companies that beat revenue and adjusted EPS. HashiCorp was the leading cloud stock to have the highest revenue beat. The company’s revenue grew by 41% YoY to $135.79 million and beat estimates by 9.3%. BILL revenue grew by 66% YoY to $260 million and beat estimates by 7%. MongoDB revenue grew by 36% YoY to $361.31 million and beat estimates by 6.9%.

Source: YCharts
MongoDB’s adjusted EPS was $0.57 compared to $0.10 for the same quarter last year. It beat analyst estimates by 656.6%.
BILL adjusted EPS came at $0.42 compared to break even for the same quarter last year. It beat analyst estimates by 210.7%.

Source: YCharts
Both MongoDB and BILL, despite the top-line and bottom-line beat, dropped after the earnings due to decelerating revenue. Per Barclays analyst Raimo Lenschow, who has an overweight rating on MongoDB, the guidance only implies 16% growth and a meaningful slowdown in the company's Atlas and Enterprise Advanced segments.
We do not place much weight on earnings beats in the current macro environment. This helps to perfectly illustrate why beats can actually be a dangerous way to evaluate a stock. In all cases – HCP, MDB and BILL, the companies were beating on decelerating revenue and/or bottom lines. We had pointed this out in our January Q1 Webinar when we stated: “We won’t be buying beats on decelerating top line or beats on deceleration bottom line.”
Bottom Line and Free Cash Flow
Below we look at the best-of-breed cloud stock’s GAAP operating margin and free cash flow margin. Note that some cloud companies are reporting better free cash margins.
Snowflake reported a higher free cash flow margin of 35% when compared to 15% in the same period last year. ServiceNow has an impressive 52% free cash flow margin when compared to 46% in the year-ago period.
GAAP profitability is another important metric to closely monitor, especially with macroeconomic uncertainty. Adobe ranks the highest in the best-of-breed cloud companies with an operating margin of 34% and ServiceNow ranks second with an operating margin of 8%.

Source: YCharts
Cloud investors should remain cautious as cutting back on expenses may weigh on growth long-term. We do not have all of the information yet on how these companies will perform a year out when they’ve decreased head count, gone remote, cut back on sales and marketing and/or cut back on R&D. During the bull market, cloud was spending for growth and this had a direct relation to helping the top line. The effects of pulling back on this spending will not be immediately seen. We are very new to cloud deceleration, which I estimate began to occur in Q3 2022. We’ve stated various reasons for this being the quarter where earnings were a bit unusual, including the Q2 beats weren’t being carried through to a full year raise on guidance.
As stated on Real Vision, this was a flag to us and we began to decrease our exposure to cloud around this time. I think we will need at least a year to 18 months to see the full effects of reduced spending in relation to the top line. Our December cloud report had said – do not be surprised if we see best-of-breed dip below 20% — and we are already quicker than I thought was possible with MDB reporting 16% growth. Perhaps I should update this and say – do not be surprised if best-of-breed reports below 10% growth. With the information we have today, we are headed in this direction.
More on Margins:
The below chart shows the GAAP operating margins of the best-of-breed cloud companies. Apart from ServiceNow and Adobe, other cloud names have negative GAAP operating margins.
Datadog was GAAP profitable but recently lost their positive margin from +3% to (7%). CrowdStrike is low negative single digits at (5%). Datadog’s management had stated in the earnings call that the previous year’s operating margin benefitted from less in-person office costs and travel costs due to Covid policies.

Source: YCharts
Stock-Based Compensation
Most of the names listed below that are unprofitable on a GAAP basis are paying high stock-based compensation. BILL has the highest percentage of stock-based compensation at 45.9%, followed by Snowflake at 42.6%, and 36.6% for SentinelOne.
The high stock-based compensation is something to be on watch for, because when companies report, they will overemphasize non-GAAP earnings. For example, BILL has a GAAP operating margin of (43%) and an adjusted operating margin of 12%, with the primary difference being stock-based compensation.
Stock-based compensation is a non-cash expense added back to adjusted earnings. However, in practice this is an expense as per GAAP rules. Warren Buffet said the following, which relates to the importance of GAAP earnings over adjusted earnings when stock-based compensation is involved. “If options aren’t a form of compensation, what are they? If compensation isn’t an expense, what is it? And if expenses should not go into the calculation of earnings, where in the world should they go?”

Source: YCharts
Valuations
In the below chart, we ranked companies based on the forward P/S ratio. Snowflake and Cloudflare have the highest forward P/S ratio. These have come down considerably over the past few months. Eventually, cloud will hit a bottom on valuations and be cheap enough for risk-adverse investors to consider.

Source: YCharts
Ranking based on revenue estimates change for current quarter.
Zscaler’s revenue estimates have been revised up 2.4% and CrowdStrike’s revenue estimates have been revised up 1.6% in the past 30 days. On the other hand, GitLab’s revenue estimates have been revised down (6.6%), Datadog’s revenue estimates have been revised down (2.6%), and MongoDB’s revenue has been revised down (1.7%). This is another reason that earnings beats are not the best way to determine the outcome of an earnings report. Because the market is forward-looking, you’ll see a company beat current estimates while being revised down on forward estimates. This is a trap that retail should try to avoid at all costs.

Source: YCharts
Ranking based on adjusted EPS estimates change for the current quarter.
MongoDB’s adjusted EPS has been revised up 47.4% in the past 30 days. We also noted earlier in our analysis that the company had a very strong adjusted EPS beat in the recent quarter. Similarly, Zscaler’s estimates have been revised up 27%, and CrowdStrike’s by 16.8%. On the other hand, Snowflake’s estimates have been revised down (26.4%) and Gitlab’s by (10.1%).

Source: YCharts
A Few Best-of-Breed highlights and lowlights in Q4.
According to the data above, Adobe and ServiceNow are best positioned to weather the new macro. This is due to favorable bottom lines, which includes the elusive GAAP profitability for this category. Their stock-based compensation ranks margin lowest on our list and their respective GAAP operating margins reflects this.
ServiceNow and Adobe also have two of the strongest free cash flow margins in the category and are essentially flat QoQ/YoY on the top line while many cloud stocks are deeply decelerating.
Crowdstrike is guiding for QoQ growth from Q4 to Q1 on both the top line and bottom line.
CrowdStrike revenue grew by 48% YoY to $637.4 million (beat estimates by 1.7%) and adjusted EPS was $0.47 (beat estimates by 10.4%). The free cash flow was also strong as it grew by 65% YoY to $209.5 million with a free cash flow margin of 33%.
Crowdstrike guided for $676M, at the midpoint and EPS of $0.50 to $0.51.
Wedbush analyst Taz Koujalgi said, "We calculate that the [annual recurring revenue] guide appears conservative, and if macro conditions do not deteriorate, net new [annual recurring revenue] growth if high single digits are doable."
The management also highlighted that the company had been ranked No.1 for the third consecutive year in IDC’s annual Worldwide Modern Endpoint Security Market. The company was able to increase its market share by 3.8% to 17.7%.
Cloudflare Grows Free Cash Flow Margin
Cloudflare revenue grew by 42% YoY to $274.7 million (beat estimates by 0.23%) and adjusted EPS was $0.06 (beat estimates by 31.6%).
The company had a free cash flow of $33.66 million with a free cash flow margin of 12% compared to a free cash flow of $8.64 million with a free cash flow margin of 4% in the year-ago quarter.
The management highlighted some of the key deals in the quarter, particularly a leading generative AI company signing a one year $1 million deal. The AI company has been a user of free tier since 2017. Cloudflare was also awarded a five-year deal of $7.2 million to operate the .gov registry. The company also got the moderate status of the FedRAMP authorization in December.
Zscaler Grows Free Cash Flow but Billings Slow
Zscaler revenue grew by 52% YoY to $387.6 million (beat estimates by 6.3%) and adjusted EPS was $0.37 (beat estimates by 26.1%). The free cash flow grew by 113% YoY to $62.8 million with a free cash flow margin of 16%. However, the weak point in the company’s report was the calculated billings that grew by 34% in the quarter from 37% growth reported in Q3 and 59% growth reported in the year-ago quarter.
The management mentioned in the earnings call, “Billings were impacted by new customers being more deliberate about their large purchasing decisions at the start of the calendar year. These deals have not gone away, and we have closed a few already in February.” The billings guide for the next quarter was also low. “For Q3 (Q1), we are assuming billings to decline by approximately 9% sequentially, compared to the mid-single digit percentage declines we have seen in the last few years.”
Conclusion
The cloud sector has many moving parts as it mixes strong product stories with weak bottom lines. In addition to this, eventually the valuations will become attractive especially for those that can weather the new macro by cutting costs and maintaining category-leading growth. Across the board, cloud investors should be prepared for a sustained slowdown on the top line. This could worsen over the next year, as typically there’s a direct relationship between spending/investing in growth and top line results 12-18 months later. The opposite will also be true, cutting back on spending/investing in growth will lead to a lower top line.
Our preference is to remain on the side lines for now while identifying the strongest one or two cloud stocks fundamentally for when the technicals show give us a clear signal that it’s time to hold exposure here again. This could happen quickly so we prefer to be prepared in advance with what companies’ charts should take priority.
Deep dives plus trade alerts and weekly webinars are offered on our premium service, you can find out more information here.
